beehiiv vs Mailchimp: Which One for a Business Newsletter?
beehiiv vs Mailchimp for a small-business newsletter people actually read: free plan limits, growth tools, and which I'd pick (and who should pick the other).
Some links here are beehiiv partner links. If you sign up through one I may earn a commission, at no cost to you. Details.
You've got a business, a pile of customer emails in a spreadsheet somewhere, and two tabs open.
beehiiv in one. Mailchimp in the other.
Short answer: if you want a newsletter people actually read, the kind with stories and behind-the-scenes stuff and a bit of personality, pick beehiiv. It was built for exactly that. Mailchimp is a solid marketing email tool, but to me it grew up sending promos, and it still feels like it.
That's the verdict.
Here's why, and who should ignore me.
The free plans aren't even close
If you're just starting out, you're probably starting free. So let's start there too.
Here's what each free plan gets you at the time of writing (November 2026), straight from each company's own site:
| beehiiv Free | Mailchimp Free | |
|---|---|---|
| Subscribers / contacts | Up to 2,500 | Up to 250 |
| Email sends | Unlimited | 500 a month, max 250 a day |
| Email automations | Not on Free (starts on Lite) | Not on Free |
| Remove the platform's branding | No (that's Pro) | No |
Two hundred and fifty contacts.
That sucks. Ten times less room than beehiiv, for the same price of zero dollars.
And it's tighter than it looks, because Mailchimp's own help docs say subscribed, unsubscribed and non-subscribed contacts all count toward your total. So the people who left still eat your limit. Go over 250 on Mailchimp's free plan and it puts a hold on sending until you upgrade (or trim the list).
beehiiv's free plan goes up to 2,500 subscribers with unlimited sends and no credit card. It also comes with a website, podcast hosting, a link-in-bio page and the Recommendation Network, which I'll get to. You can start on beehiiv's free plan here and not pay a cent until you're waaayyy past the "is this even working?" stage.
Sure, the free plan isn't everything. But when you're starting from zero, the one that lets you reach ten times as many people for $0 matters.
What each one was actually built for
Okay, this is the real difference, and it's less about features and more about what the tool expects you to do.
Open Mailchimp's pricing page and you'll see marketing automation flows, predictive segmentation, generative AI features, multivariate testing. It's a marketing machine. Totally legit. It's just pointed at "get this person to buy," and the whole thing feels built for the 20%-off-this-weekend email.
beehiiv feels built by people who wanted newsletters to grow. Almost every tool points at "get more people reading, and keep them reading":
- Referral program (Lite and up). Readers share your newsletter and earn rewards you pick. Say you run a bakery: 3 referrals gets a free cookie, 10 gets a loaf. Your best customers turn into your marketing department, and they work for cookies.
- Recommendation Network (every plan, free included). Other beehiiv newsletters recommend yours to their readers, and you recommend theirs. Free growth, basically.
- Polls and surveys (Lite and up). "Which flavor should we bring back?" right inside the email. One click to answer. People love it, and you actually learn something.
- A real website (every plan). Every issue lives on the web as a post, so your newsletter doubles as your blog. One less thing to build.
- Ad Network (Lite and up). beehiiv calls it "the industry's largest native ad network." Once you've got readers, sponsors can pay to be in front of them.
- Paid subscriptions (Lite and up). beehiiv takes 0% of paid-subscription revenue, you just pay Stripe's normal processing fee. (Substack takes 10%, for comparison.)
That last one probably doesn't matter to a plumber. Fine.
But referrals and polls? Those matter to everybody.
For what it's worth, I send the Start Here newsletter on beehiiv. Not because it's shiny. Because the whole thing is built around the issue, not the coupon.
Who should actually pick Mailchimp
Gotta be fair here.
If your business is mostly an online store, and what you really want is automated "hey, you left something in your cart" emails, Mailchimp does that. It has abandoned cart emails built in and connects with a ton of store platforms (Shopify, WooCommerce, Square, Wix and Squarespace are all on its popular list). If store-triggered emails are 90% of what you send, Mailchimp makes sense.
But that's a different job.
A cart reminder is plumbing. A newsletter is the reason people stick around.
Most small businesses don't need a sales machine first. They need people to actually open the damn email.
Why a story-first newsletter belongs on beehiiv
Here's the thing nobody says out loud: the tool shapes what you write.
Open a tool built around campaigns and you'll start writing campaigns. Big SHOP NOW buttons. Subject lines with percent signs in them. And that's how you end up in the Promotions tab, unread, wedged between every other coupon in the inbox. (I wrote a whole post on why nobody opens your newsletter, if that one stings a little 😅)
Open beehiiv and it feels like a place to write.
Picture a dog groomer. This week's issue is "the poodle who tried to fight the blow dryer," a short story with one photo, a poll at the bottom ("what's your dog's worst bath-time move?"), and a little line under it: share this with a friend, get a free nail trim. That's a newsletter people forward. It's also a newsletter beehiiv is set up for, top to bottom, the story, the poll, the referral, all in one place.
No idea what to write? Here's a pile of newsletter ideas for small businesses. The behind-the-scenes issue is the easiest one to start with, honestly.
And when you outgrow the free plan, the stuff you pay for on beehiiv mostly helps the list grow. Referrals. Polls. Ads. Paid subscriptions where beehiiv takes none of the money. On Mailchimp, upgrading mostly buys you more marketing machinery. That's my read of the two pricing pages, anyway.
Yeah, Mailchimp's been the default name for years. Doesn't make it the right tool for this.
If you want the longer version of my reasoning, it's all on why I use beehiiv.
So, which one?
Running an online store, and mostly need cart and order emails? Mailchimp's fine. Really.
Want a newsletter people open, reply to, and forward to their sister? beehiiv. No contest.
Here's what I'd do. Start on beehiiv's free plan, write something true about your business, and send three issues. Just three. 2,500 subscribers is a lot of runway, and you'll know way before then if people care.
So what's the first story you'd send? The one your customers don't know yet?
Keep reading
25 Newsletter Ideas for Small Businesses (No Coupons)
25 newsletter ideas for small business owners: stories, useful tips, community picks and selling done right, each with a real example you can steal this week.
Behind-the-Scenes Newsletter: Turn a Tuesday Into a Story
How to write a behind the scenes newsletter from what already happened this week: spot the story, use a 5-step shape, steal a sample issue, grab 13 prompts.
Why Nobody Opens Your Business Newsletter
Your business newsletter gets ignored because every issue is a sales blast. Here's the story letter fix, a before/after example, and a shape you can reuse.