Behind-the-Scenes Newsletter: Turn a Tuesday Into a Story
How to write a behind the scenes newsletter from what already happened this week: spot the story, use a 5-step shape, steal a sample issue, grab 13 prompts.
Some links here are beehiiv partner links. If you sign up through one I may earn a commission, at no cost to you. Details.
The flour came wrong.
You ordered bread flour, eight fifty-pound bags, and the guy wheeled in rye. At 6am. With a line already forming.
That's your newsletter this week. Seriously.
A behind the scenes newsletter is a short email about something that actually happened in your business this week, told like a story, with one light line at the end about what you sell. It's the easiest issue you'll ever write, because you don't have to invent anything. You already lived it. You just have to notice it and put it in the right order.
Sooo much easier than dreaming up another promo.
Here's how I'd do it.
Why the ordinary stuff works
Nobody signed up for your list to read a catalog. (If your opens are already sad, I wrote about why nobody opens your newsletter, and spoiler, the catalog thing is a big part of it.)
They signed up because they like you. Or your shop. Or the way your place smells on a Saturday morning.
Behind-the-scenes stuff gives them more of that. The wrong delivery, the broken mixer, the customer who's ordered the same sandwich for three years. That's the part of your business they never get to see, and it's the part that makes them feel like insiders.
That's the whole trick of newsletter storytelling for business, really. Anyone can run a 15% off sale.
Nobody else had your Tuesday.
How to spot a story in a boring day
Most owners say "nothing happened this week."
Something always happened. You just filed it under "annoying as hell" instead of "story."
Look for these:
- Something went wrong. The delivery, the printer, the walk-in cooler making that noise again.
- Something surprised you. A customer asked for a thing you'd never thought of selling.
- Somebody did something human. The regular who always orders the same thing finally, after two years, ordered something different. (Why?? You need to know. So do your readers.)
- You made a call. Turned down a job, changed a recipe, fixed a problem in a weird way.
The test is simple. If you'd tell it to a friend over a beer, it counts. If you'd only tell it to your accountant, skip it.
Keep a note on your phone. When something dumb or funny or annoying happens, type three words. "Rye flour, 6am." That's enough to rebuild the whole thing on Friday.
The 5-step shape
Every behind-the-scenes issue I'd write hangs on the same rough shape. Think of it as a coat hanger for the story.
- The moment. Drop the reader right in. "The flour came wrong." Not "This week we want to share an update about our supply chain." God, no.
- What went wrong, or what surprised you. One or two lines. Make it physical. Fifty-pound bags. The wrong color. The time on the clock.
- What you did. This is the meat. The fix, the improvising, the call you made.
- What it says about how you work. One line, maybe two. Don't preach.
- One light line about what you sell. "The rye's on the shelf till Saturday." That's it.
Step 5 is where most people blow it. They write a lovely little story and then staple a sales flyer to the bottom.
Keep it to a sentence. The story already did the selling.
(Want more formats beyond this one? Here's my list of newsletter ideas for small business.)
A sample issue (made-up bakery)
Here's the whole thing written out. The bakery is made up. Call it Low Oven Bakery: tiny corner spot, two ovens, one very tired owner named Rosa.
Subject: The flour guy brought the wrong flour
Tuesday, 6:04am. The delivery guy wheels in eight bags of flour.
Rye. All eight.
I ordered bread flour. The sourdough, the baguettes, the sandwich loaves, all of it runs on bread flour, and I had enough left for maybe one batch.
So I had a choice. Close early, or get weird.
We got weird. Half-rye sourdough, darker, a little sour, honestly kind of great. A rye chocolate cookie that Marco swore would flop and then ate four of. We wrote "Rye Week (not on purpose)" on the chalkboard and leaned in.
Best part: Mr. Okafor, who has ordered a plain baguette every morning since we opened, asked for the rye. First new order in two years. He said it "tastes like a Sunday." I don't know what that means but I'm keeping it.
The right flour shows up Thursday. But I'd rather change the menu for a week than sell you a loaf I'm not proud of. That's kind of the whole deal here.
Rye Week runs till Saturday. We're usually out of the half-rye by ten.
Rosa
About 200 words. Maybe 20 minutes to write. (Hypothetical minutes, Rosa isn't real, but you get it.)
Notice what's not in there. No "Dear valued customers." No "We're excited to announce." No damn discount code.
And step 4 is one sentence. It should be.
Set it up once, reuse it every week
This is where your newsletter tool actually matters.
I send the Start Here newsletter on beehiiv, and the first thing I'd do for a behind-the-scenes issue is build the shape once and save it as a template. Five headings: moment, what went wrong, what you did, what it says, the light line. Next week you open the template, write under each heading, delete the headings, send. No blank page staring back at you.
Two more things worth knowing.
You can start free. beehiiv's free plan goes up to 2,500 subscribers, with unlimited sends and no credit card. For a corner bakery, that's a lot of runway.
Polls turn the story into a conversation. On the paid plans (Lite and up) you get polls, so you can end an issue with "Should Rye Week come back? Yes / No / Only the cookie." Readers click, you learn something, and next week's issue basically writes itself. Way better than sending into the void and hearing nothing back, which sucks.
That's a big part of why I think beehiiv beats the old-school email tools for this kind of letter. It was built for emails people read, not for blasting promos. I go deeper on that in why beehiiv, and if you're stuck choosing, here's beehiiv vs Mailchimp. Or just grab the free plan and write the flour story.
The sticky note: 13 story prompts
(It was going to be 10. I couldn't stop.)
Write these on a sticky note. Put it on the register, the truck dash, the fridge, wherever you are when it's slow.
- What broke this week?
- What delivery came wrong, late, or weird?
- Which regular did something different?
- What did a customer ask for that you don't sell? Yet.
- What did you almost stop doing?
- What took waaayyy longer than it should have?
- What's one thing you do every day that nobody notices?
- Who on your team saved the day, even a little?
- What did you change your mind about?
- What's the dumbest question you got, and was it actually dumb?
- What did you try for the first time?
- What does a dead-slow hour look like at your place?
- What would you never sell, and why?
Pick one a week. That's three months of issues right there, and by then you'll be spotting stories without the note.
So, what happened this Tuesday?
Skip the big stuff. Think about the thing you complained about at lunch.
That's the issue. Five steps, one line of selling, send.
What's the story from your week you almost didn't think counted?
Keep reading
Why Nobody Opens Your Business Newsletter
Your business newsletter gets ignored because every issue is a sales blast. Here's the story letter fix, a before/after example, and a shape you can reuse.
25 Newsletter Ideas for Small Businesses (No Coupons)
25 newsletter ideas for small business owners: stories, useful tips, community picks and selling done right, each with a real example you can steal this week.
beehiiv vs Mailchimp: Which One for a Business Newsletter?
beehiiv vs Mailchimp for a small-business newsletter people actually read: free plan limits, growth tools, and which I'd pick (and who should pick the other).